Merry Witchmas: A Wicked Witches of the Midwest Short

I dove into Merry Witchmas expecting a lighthearted holiday romp and wasn’t disappointed. Maria Hostage’s narration is a perfect match for Tillie’s sharp wit, her delivery oscillating seamlessly between deadpan sarcasm and earnest emotional beats. The story itself is a masterclass in cozy mystery structure—complete with quirky townsfolk, magical mishaps, and a murder that’s just gruesome enough to keep things interesting. While the mystery resolves a tad conveniently, the real joy lies in Tillie’s unapologetic attitude and the world-building that longtime fans of the series will devour. If I have a quibble, it’s that the supporting characters occasionally feel underdeveloped, but the audiobook’s brisk runtime (just over three hours) ensures the pacing never lags. Production quality is crisp, with Hostage’s vocal range adding depth to even the most eccentric characters. This might not be the most complex whodunit, but as a festive, fun diversion? It’s pure magic.