When

Whitney Dykhouse’s narration is a standout feature, imbuing Maddie and her classmates with distinct voices that bring depth to each character. Her subtle delivery perfectly matches the book's tone of both mystery and growing self-discovery. The plot unfolds at a brisk pace, keeping listeners on their toes as Maddie navigates the intricacies of high school while grappling with life-altering revelations. However, some scenes feel rushed, particularly when transitioning between Maddie’s internal monologues and external events. Despite this minor hiccup, When is an engrossing listen that will keep you guessing until the very end.