My First Mistake

Name: My First Mistake
Availability: InStock
Rating: 4.7 (4 reviews)
Author: Sadie Kincaid

Heartbreak, Humor, and Homecoming

Written bySadie Kincaid

Narrated byMollie Stark, Joe Arden

Length5h24m

Release dateDecember 17, 2025

GenreRomance, Contemporary

LanguageEnglish

★★★★☆ 4.7 (4 ratings)

Listen Free on Audible

Free with Audible trial. Cancel anytime.

Available Worldwide

Listen Free

Listen Free

Listen to a Sample

Hear Mollie Stark, Joe Arden's narration on Audible.

Play Sample on Audible

Quick Facts

Author	Sadie Kincaid
Narrator	Mollie Stark, Joe Arden
Runtime	5h24m
Published	December 17, 2025
Rating	★★★★☆ 4.7 / 5 (4 ratings)
Categories	Romance, Contemporary
Format	Audiobook (Digital)
Platform	Audible

About This Audiobook

Sadie Kincaid's 'My First Mistake' is a heartwarming, heart-wrenching tale of love, loss, and second chances. Narrated by Mollie Stark and Joe Arden, this dual-perspective romance is a rollercoaster of emotions, with Stark's warm, comforting voice guiding us through the heroine's pain and Arden's smooth, resonant tones bringing depth to the enigmatic best man. Kincaid's writing is sharp and witty, making even the most painful moments bearable, while her characters are as real and flawed as your best friends. This audiobook is distinctive in its blend of humor and heartache, making it a must-listen for fans of contemporary romance.

Tags: Contemporary RomanceSecond Chance LoveHeartbreak and HealingWedding DramaDual NarratorEmotional Rollercoaster

Why Listen to My First Mistake?

Expert narration by Mollie Stark, Joe Arden brings every character and scene to life across 5h24m of immersive audio.
Highly rated at 4.7 stars by 4 listeners.
Free with your Audible trial — keep the audiobook forever even if you cancel.
Perfect for commutes, workouts, and relaxation. Listen anywhere, anytime.

Start Listening Free

Editor's Review ★★★★☆

AudioBook Atlas

I dove into 'My First Mistake' expecting a light, fluffy romance, but Kincaid had other plans. She doesn't shy away from the harsh realities of heartbreak and betrayal, making the story feel authentic and raw. Stark and Arden's narration is exceptional, bringing out the best in Kincaid's characters and making me feel like I was right there with them. The pacing is spot-on, keeping me engaged and eager to find out what happens next. My only critique is that the epilogue felt a bit rushed, but it didn't detract from the overall enjoyment of the story. This audiobook is a perfect blend of laughter and tears, making it a standout in the contemporary romance genre.

Download: My First Mistake

Some links on this page are affiliate links. If you make a purchase through one of them, we may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you.

Free Download on Audible USA

My First Mistake by Sadie Kincaid is an immersive listening experience. Performed by Mollie Stark, Joe Arden with a runtime of 5h24m, you can start with a free trial that you can cancel at any time. The audiobook remains yours forever, even if you end the trial.