Not Your Crush's Cauldron by April Asher

Not Your Crush's Cauldron

Witchy Rom-Com with Bite and Heart

Written byApril Asher
Narrated byZura Johnson
Length11h37m
Release dateFebruary 13, 2024
LanguageEnglish
★★★★☆ 4.7 (39 ratings)

Free with Audible trial. Cancel anytime.

Listen to a Sample

Hear Zura Johnson's narration on Audible.

Play Sample on Audible

Quick Facts

AuthorApril Asher
NarratorZura Johnson
Runtime11h37m
PublishedFebruary 13, 2024
Rating★★★★☆ 4.7 / 5 (39 ratings)
CategoriesRomance, Paranormal, Romantic Comedy
FormatAudiobook (Digital)
PlatformAudible

About This Audiobook

*Not Your Crush’s Cauldron* is the paranormal rom-com equivalent of a perfectly brewed espresso martini—sharp, effervescent, and leaving you slightly buzzed with delight. April Asher’s witchy world isn’t just broomsticks and love potions; it’s a snarky, self-aware romp where the magic feels as real as the emotional baggage. Olive Maxwell, our reluctant heroine, is the kind of protagonist you’d follow into a cursed antique shop: a college professor who lectures on the supernatural but flinches at actual spells, stuck between her chaos-goblin sisters and a love interest who’s *way* too charming for her own good. The audiobook thrives on this tension—between duty and desire, logic and lunacy—delivered with Zura Johnson’s narration, which nails Olive’s dry wit and the slow-burn chemistry that simmers beneath every snarky exchange.

What sets this apart from the crowded witchy-romance shelf? The humor isn’t just punchlines; it’s baked into the worldbuilding, from Olive’s *practical* approach to magic (think spreadsheets for spellwork) to the way Asher subverts tropes without winking at the camera. Johnson’s performance leans into the absurdity—her timing on Olive’s exasperated mutters and the love interest’s smug drawl is *chef’s kiss*—but never at the expense of the story’s heart. The pacing clips along like a cauldron about to boil over, balancing steamy tension with genuine stakes. If you’ve ever rolled your eyes at a “chosen one” narrative or wished rom-coms had more teeth, this is your audiobook.

Tags: witchy romantic comedy audiobooksparanormal romance with humorslow-burn enemies-to-lovers audiosarcastic heroine fantasy romancemagical academia rom-comdiverse paranormal romance 2020s

Why Listen to Not Your Crush's Cauldron?

  • Expert narration by Zura Johnson brings every character and scene to life across 11h37m of immersive audio.
  • Highly rated at 4.7 stars by 39 listeners.
  • Free with your Audible trial — keep the audiobook forever even if you cancel.
  • Perfect for commutes, workouts, and relaxation. Listen anywhere, anytime.
Start Listening Free
AE

Editor's Review ★★★★☆

AudioBook Atlas

I’ll admit: I side-eyed the premise at first. *Another* witchy romance? But *Not Your Crush’s Cauldron* won me over in the first chapter—not with grand magic, but with Olive’s *vibes*. She’s the kind of protagonist who’d rather grade papers than cast a love spell, and Zura Johnson’s narration makes her relatable without being whiny. Johnson’s real strength is her versatility: she slides from Olive’s academic deadpan to the love interest’s honeyed teasing without missing a beat, and the secondary characters (especially Olive’s disaster sisters) get distinct, memorable voices. The production is clean, with no jarring edits or volume spikes—just a smooth listen that lets the story’s charm shine. That said, the middle act drags slightly. Asher’s worldbuilding is clever (I adore the idea of magical academia clashing with real-world bureaucracy), but a few subplots—like Olive’s student projects—feel undercooked compared to the central romance. And while the banter is *excellent*, there’s a point where the will-they-won’t-they starts to feel like a stall tactic. Still, the payoff is worth it: the last third delivers emotional gut-punches alongside the laughs, and Johnson’s delivery during the more vulnerable scenes (particularly Olive’s monologue about fear) is stunning. If you love rom-coms with bite, heroines who grow *because* of their flaws, and narrators who make snark sound like an art form, this is a must-listen. Just maybe speed up the playback to 1.2x during the slower stretches.

Download: Not Your Crush's Cauldron

Some links on this page are affiliate links. If you make a purchase through one of them, we may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you.

Not Your Crush's Cauldron by April Asher is an immersive listening experience. Performed by Zura Johnson with a runtime of 11h37m, you can start with a free trial that you can cancel at any time. The audiobook remains yours forever, even if you end the trial.