When in Rome

The dual narration by Karissa Vacker and Andrew Eiden is the audiobook’s secret weapon—Vacker nails the brittle, self-aware cadence of a pop star who’s spent too many years performing for crowds and not enough time for herself, while Eiden’s rich, conversational tone makes the small-town baker feel like the kind of guy you’d want to share a plate of cacio e pepe with. Their chemistry crackles during the early “enemies with benefits” setup, but the real magic happens midway when the performances deepen into something achingly human—Vacker’s voice cracks with vulnerability during a late-night confession, and Eiden’s gentle rasp hits hard when delivering a quiet moment of self-reckoning. Structurally, the book stumbles slightly in its third act by rushing through the fallout of their biggest lie, which feels less like a satisfying resolution and more like a montage skimmed from a rom-com highlight reel. The production itself is flawless, with seamless chapter transitions and subtle ambient sounds (clinking espresso cups, distant Vespas) that immerse you in Rome without ever feeling gimmicky. If you’re a fan of slow-burn romance with sharp dialogue and messy, relatable characters, this is a standout that proves Adams is more than a viral sensation—she’s a storyteller who understands the difference between a crush and a connection.