Butter Witch by Tess Lake

Butter Witch

A chilling murder mystery with witchy charm

Written byTess Lake
Narrated byNatalie Duke
Length6h31m
Release dateJuly 20, 2016
LanguageEnglish
★★★★ 4.2 (26 ratings)

Free with Audible trial. Cancel anytime.

Listen to a Sample

Hear Natalie Duke's narration on Audible.

Play Sample on Audible

Quick Facts

AuthorTess Lake
NarratorNatalie Duke
Runtime6h31m
PublishedJuly 20, 2016
Rating★★★★ 4.2 / 5 (26 ratings)
CategoriesMystery, Thriller & Suspense, Mystery, Cozy, Women Sleuths, Thriller & Suspense, Supernatural
FormatAudiobook (Digital)
PlatformAudible

About This Audiobook

Tess Lake’s *Butter Witch* is a brisk, sunlit nightmare—where idyllic small-town vibes cloak something far more sinister. Harlow Torrent, a journalist with a knack for Slip magic, stumbles upon a corpse frozen solid and suspiciously bloodless, its hollowed-out veins a puzzle even the town’s witchy rumor mill can’t crack. Lake’s prose crackles with dry wit and frostbitten dread, blending cozy mystery tropes with a dash of supernatural grit. The story’s real strength lies in its atmosphere: Lake doesn’t just describe a scene—she marinates you in it, from the scent of cinnamon and potpourri wafting through the local diner to the unsettling quiet of a murderer who leaves no fingerprints, only ice. Natalie Duke’s narration is the cherry on top, her clear, measured cadence shifting seamlessly between Harlow’s sardonic inner monologue and the tense exchanges of local gossip. Duke’s voice has the rare ability to make even mundane dialogue feel urgent, her delivery as sharp as the knife Harlow insists on carrying. If you’ve ever wanted a mystery where the real magic is the unraveling of small-town secrets, this is your brew.

Tags: cozy mystery with dark undertonessupernatural murder mysterysmall-town secrets audiobookfemale-led witch mysteryNatalie Duke narrationfrozen body mystery

Why Listen to Butter Witch?

  • Expert narration by Natalie Duke brings every character and scene to life across 6h31m of immersive audio.
  • Highly rated at 4.2 stars by 26 listeners.
  • Free with your Audible trial — keep the audiobook forever even if you cancel.
  • Perfect for commutes, workouts, and relaxation. Listen anywhere, anytime.
Start Listening Free
AE

Editor's Review ★★★★

AudioBook Atlas

I went into *Butter Witch* expecting a light cozy mystery with a magical twist, but Lake delivers something far more layered—and Natalie Duke’s narration elevates it to near-perfect. Duke’s voice is the audiobook’s secret weapon: she nails Harlow’s dry, skeptical tone without overplaying it, and her transitions between characters are seamless. The murder victim’s frozen state is described with such vivid horror—I could almost feel the cold seeping through my headphones—yet the story never loses its sense of humor. Harlow’s Slip magic, a quiet but persistent thread, adds a fresh layer to the genre without derailing the mystery. My only critique? The pacing stumbles slightly in the middle act, where Harlow’s investigations drag a bit before the stakes reset with a jolt. That said, the payoff is worth it. The final confrontation, played out in a snowbound diner with Harlow’s magic and a side of betrayal, is tense and satisfying. If you’re a fan of mysteries where the setting feels like a character—dripping with atmosphere and just a hint of danger—this is a standout. Duke’s performance alone makes it a must-listen for audiobook devotees.

Download: Butter Witch

Some links on this page are affiliate links. If you make a purchase through one of them, we may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you.

Butter Witch by Tess Lake is an immersive listening experience. Performed by Natalie Duke with a runtime of 6h31m, you can start with a free trial that you can cancel at any time. The audiobook remains yours forever, even if you end the trial.