The Witch Squad Cozy Mystery Series, Books 4-6

About This Audiobook

If you crave mystery with a side of supernatural spice, the Witch Squad series delivers exactly that—three tightly plotted, witchy whodunits wrapped in humor and heart. Book Four, Witch Pie, throws Mercy Thompson and her coven into a battle of baked goods and betrayal when a beloved local baker turns up dead amid a high-stakes pie contest. The tension is thick enough to cut with a ceremonial athame, but Andrews keeps the tone breezy, balancing dark deeds with laugh-out-loud banter between the witches. This isn’t your grandma’s cozy mystery; it’s a cauldron of chaos where spells go awry and secrets fester like over-risen dough.

In Book Five, A Very Mercy Christmas, the holiday cheer in Hollow’s End curdles when a missing person’s case stirs up old grudges and buried magic. Andrews shines in her ability to blend festive cheer with creeping dread, wrapping the mystery in tinsel and twinkling lights before yanking the rug out. Book Six, Where Witches Lie, takes the squad deeper into the town’s dark past, uncovering a conspiracy that’s less about curses and more about human malice—proving these witches are as sharp as their senses. The audiobook’s strength lies in Andrews’ knack for snappy dialogue and Lisa Cordileone’s narration, which gives every character—from the snarky witch to the slow-witted deputy—a distinct, memorable voice.