Bewitchments & Bookworms

Hollis McCarthy’s narration is the secret sauce that elevates Bewitchments & Bookworms from a charming cozy mystery to an immersive listening experience. Her voice has a rich, honeyed warmth that’s perfect for Rory, a protagonist who’s equal parts bookish and briskly competent, but the real magic happens when she shifts into the sinister or the snarky. McCarthy nails the tonal balance, slipping between gentle humor and creeping dread so seamlessly that the shift from a cozy library chat to a séance in the basement feels thrilling, not jarring. The production is crisp, with subtle sound design that enhances the atmosphere without overshadowing the story—think of a crackling fire in the hearth or the rustle of old parchment, just loud enough to feel like you’re there. That said, there were a few moments where the pacing dragged slightly, particularly in the middle act where the mystery’s threads are being laid out. It’s not enough to break the spell, but it did make me wish for a bit more urgency in a couple of scenes that could’ve used a sharper tug on the reins. That nitpick aside, the chemistry between McCarthy and the source material is undeniable. She makes Rory’s world feel lived-in, from the way she pronounces the old spellbooks to the exasperation in her voice when another cursed tome leads her into trouble. If you’re a fan of audiobooks that make you forget you’re listening and not just reading, this is a standout. Just don’t blame me if you have to order your own set of protective charms after finishing it.