Witch Brew

Narrator Dillon Horinek doesn’t just voice this story—he serves it up with a side of menace and a dash of dark comedy, making Witch Brew’s blend of mystery and horror feel as immersive as a cracked egg yolk left in the sun. His performance nails Jack Daniels’ world-weariness, switching effortlessly from exhausted mom-mode to razor-sharp interrogation without ever sounding like he’s phoning it in. The real standout is his handling of the B&B’s cult-like atmosphere; his voice for the host, Chandler, drips with false warmth that makes your skin crawl, while the side characters—especially Phineas Troutt—feel like real, flawed people rather than caricatures. Production-wise, the audio is crisp enough to catch the eerie silence between Jack’s sarcastic quips, but Horinek’s strength is in making even the most mundane lines feel like a threat waiting to unfold. My only gripe? The escape room chapter feels underutilized—it’s a fun set piece, but the pacing drags just enough to make me wish it’d either been expanded or streamlined. And while the body count keeps rising, the resolution leans a bit too hard on the series’ usual schtick without adding anything new. Still, if you’re craving a mystery where the real recipe is “kill first, ask questions never,” Horinek’s narration turns this into a deliciously sleazy listen.